Jimmy goes to a record studio to pick up a Popularity Award, to find that the disc jockey is Boris Karloff. Boris invites Jimmy to his home for the weekend to show Jimmy what a gentle man he really is.
Rudy interviews Elsa Maxwell about her visit to the castle of Baron Rothschild. Douglas Montgomery and Shirley Booth perform the play Three Diamond Bid. Rudy introduces the first radio appearance of Edgar Bergen and Charlie McCarthy. Cornelia Otis Skinner performs a Christmas play.
Orson Welles stars as a man who never wanted to gamble until he hears about an old woman who knows the secret of always winning at cards. He becomes obsessed with getting the secret from her to the point of murder.